By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Pew PatriotsPew PatriotsPew Patriots
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • News
  • Tactical
  • Guns and Gear
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
Reading: Supreme Court flare ups grab headlines as justices feel the heat
Share
Font ResizerAa
Pew PatriotsPew Patriots
  • News
  • Tactical
  • Guns and Gear
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
Search
  • Home
  • News
  • Tactical
  • Guns and Gear
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
Supreme Court flare ups grab headlines as justices feel the heat
News

Supreme Court flare ups grab headlines as justices feel the heat

Jimmie Dempsey
Last updated: May 6, 2025 1:15 pm
Jimmie Dempsey Published May 6, 2025
Share
SHARE

Tensions on the Supreme Court have flared this term as justices have clashed with each other and with lawyers at oral arguments amid a wave of Trump-era emergency appeals. 

These exchanges at any other forum would hardly even raise an eyebrow. But at the Supreme Court, where decorum and respect are bedrock principles and underpin even the most casual cross-talk between justices, these recent clashes are significant. 

After one particularly acrimonious exchange, several longtime Supreme Court watchers noted that the behavior displayed was unlike anything they’d seen in “decades” of covering the high court.

Here are two high-profile Supreme Court spats that have made headlines in recent weeks.

100 DAYS OF INJUNCTIONS, TRIALS AND ‘TEFLON DON’: TRUMP SECOND TERM MEETS ITS BIGGEST TESTS IN COURT

Mahmoud v. Taylor

Last month, Supreme Court Justices Samuel Alito and Sonia Sotomayor quarreled briefly during oral arguments in Mahmoud v. Taylor, a case focused on LGBTQ-related books in elementary schools and whether parents with religious objections can “opt out” children being read such material. 

The exhange occurred when Sotomayor asked Mahmoud attorney Eric Baxter about a book titled “Uncle Bobby’s Wedding,” a story that invoked a same-sex relationship. Sotomayor asked Baxter whether exposure to same-sex relationships in children’s books like the one in question should be considered “coercion.”

Baxter began responding when Alito chimed in.

“I’ve read that book as well as a lot of these other books,” Alito said. “Do you think it’s fair to say that all that is done in ‘Uncle Bobby’s Wedding’ is to expose children to the fact that there are men who marry other men?”

After Baxter objected, Alito noted that the book in question “has a clear message” but one that some individuals with “traditional religious beliefs don’t agree with.”

Sotomayor jumped in partway through Alito’s objection, “What a minute, the reservation is – “

“Can I finish?” Alito said to Sotomayor in a rare moment of frustration. 

He continued, “It has a clear moral message, and it may be a good message. It’s just a message that a lot of religious people disagree with.”

TRUMP ADMINISTRATION ASKS SUPREME COURT TO REVIEW EL SALVADOR DEPORTATION FLIGHT CASE

Gorsuch at 2024 State of the Union

“There is a growing heat to the exchanges between the justices,” Fox News contributor Jonathan Turley observed on social media after the exchange. 

A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schools

The Sotomayor-Alito spat made some court-watchers uncomfortable. But it paled in comparison to the heated, tense exchange that played out just one week later between Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch and Lisa Blatt, a litigator from the firm Williams & Connolly.

The exchange took place during oral arguments in A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schools, a case about whether school districts can be held liable for discriminating against students with disabilities under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. 

Gorsuch scolded Blatt, an experienced Supreme Court litigator who was representing the public schools in the case, after she accused the other side of “lying.” 

What played out was a remarkably heated exchange, if only by Supreme Court standards. Several court observers noted that they had never seen Gorsuch so angry, and others remarked they had never seen counsel accuse the other side of “lying.”

Supreme Court Justice nominee Neil Gorsuch meets with Senate Judiciary Committee member Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., Wednesday, Feb. 8, 2017, on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)

“You believe that Mr. Martinez and the Solicitor General are lying? Is that your accusation?” Gorsuch asked Blatt, who fired back, “Yes, absolutely.”

 Counsel “should be more careful with their words,” Gorsuch told Blatt in an early tone of warning.

“OK, well, they should be more careful in mischaracterizing a position by an experienced advocate of the Supreme Court, with all due respect,” Blatt responded.

Several minutes later, Gorsuch referenced the lying accusation again, “Ms. Blatt, I confess I’m still troubled by your suggestion that your friends on the other side have lied.”

“I’d ask you to reconsider that phrase,” he said. “You can accuse people of being incorrect, but lying, lying is another matter.”

He then began to read through quotations that she had entered before the court, before she interrupted again. 

“I’m not finished,” Gorsuch told Blatt, raising his voice.

“Fine,” she responded.

Shortly after, Gorsuch asked Blatt to withdraw her earlier remarks that accused the other side of lying.

“Withdraw your accusation, Ms. Blatt,” Gorsuch said.

“Fine, I withdraw,” she shot back.

Plaintiffs said in rebuttal that they would not dignify the name-calling.

Supreme Court

The exchange sparked some buzz online, including from an experienced appeals court litigator, Raffi Melkonian, who wrote on social media, “I’ve never heard Justice Gorsuch so angry.”

“Both of those moments literally stopped me in my tracks,” said Steve Vladeck, a professor at the Georgetown University Law Center. “You might want to listen somewhere where you can cringe in peace.”

‪Mark Joseph Stern‬, a court reporter for Slate, described the exchange as “extremely tense” and described Blatt’s behavior as “indignant and unrepentant.”

Read the full article here

You Might Also Like

Netflix film tells true story of only predominantly Black and female army battalion to serve during WWII

Giants agree to sign Jameis Winston to help fill quarterback void

Rubio warns court order blocking deportations to South Sudan causes ‘irreparable harm’ to foreign policy

Gal Gadot diagnosed with brain blood clot, underwent emergency surgery while 8 months pregnant

What is the NHL’s 4 Nations Face-Off? Here’s what you need to know

Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We Recommend
Washington state father wanted for murder after 3 daughters found dead
News

Washington state father wanted for murder after 3 daughters found dead

Jimmie Dempsey Jimmie Dempsey June 4, 2025
UAE AMBASSADOR YOUSEF AL OTAIBA: US and UAE forge groundbreaking high-tech partnership based on AI
Couple unearths ‘highly revered’ Ancient Roman rarity during volunteer dig at tourist site
Ex-boxer opens up about being granted clemency by Trump and the president potentially pardoning Diddy
Wake Forest baseball coach apologizes for homophobic slur caught on camera during NCAA Tournament game
House Republicans push for spending cancellations as Elon Musk and conservatives demand deeper budget cuts
Karen Read’s silence in murder trial raises stakes for defense
News

Karen Read’s silence in murder trial raises stakes for defense

Jimmie Dempsey Jimmie Dempsey June 4, 2025
Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ faces resistance from Republican senators over debt fears
News

Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ faces resistance from Republican senators over debt fears

Jimmie Dempsey Jimmie Dempsey June 4, 2025
Source of death threats against Astros pitcher Lance McCullers identified as ‘inebriated’ bettor, police say
News

Source of death threats against Astros pitcher Lance McCullers identified as ‘inebriated’ bettor, police say

Jimmie Dempsey Jimmie Dempsey June 4, 2025
Pew Patriots
  • News
  • Tactical
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
  • Guns and Gear
2024 © Pew Patriots. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?